出刊年月/Date of Publishing

2003.03

所屬卷期/Vol. & No.   第33卷第1期 Vol. 33, No. 1

類型/Type                 研究論文 Research Article

篇名/Title
科學概念的指稱與投射
Reference and Projection of Scientific Concepts

作者/Author
陳瑞麟 Ruey-Lin Chen

頁碼/Pagination
pp. 125-192

摘要
本文將論證，針對說明「科學語詞 (也就是「科學概念」) 和世界的關係」這個議題上，分析傳統的「指稱的因果理論」和「指稱」觀念兩者都將面對難以解決的困境。「投射」的觀念才是更好的途徑，科學語詞和科學概念是透過「投射」而和世界建立一定的相互關係。

本文試圖提出一個科學概念的「經驗投射理論」。我們將以量熱學、熱力學、燃素理論等等實際的科學案例，來詳細論證下列論旨：1. 心智將科學概念投射到世界，並建構可落實模型來印證它們。2. 每個科學概念是一概念網絡的一部分。3. 科學概念與現象的關聯由其在概念網絡中的位置來決定。4. 科學概念投射的對象被落實後，此概念才指稱該被落實的物體。5. 出現在不同理論中的語詞對應了不同的科學概念。

Abstract
What is the relation between scientific terms (scientific concepts) and the world? In this article I argue that the several versions of causal theory of reference fail to provide a good answer to this question. As the notion of reference is presupposed, the versions encounter some unsolvable difficulties. But there is a better approach along the notion of projection. I claim that some degree of correlation between scientific terms or concepts and the world can be established through projection

This article proposes and develops an Empirical Projection Theory (EPT) for scientific concepts. The theory exhibits an essential characteristic of the scientific concept: empirical projectibility. EPT claims the following theses. (1) Scientific concepts can be projected onto the world by the mind and confirmed by constructing realizable models. (2) Each scientific concept is a part of a conceptual network that is constituted by a classificatory system. (3) The correlation between each scientific concept and phenomena depends on the concept’s topological location or the way it is linked to the other concepts. (4) When the object projected by a scientific concept is confirmed or realized, the scientific concept and its correspondent scientific term refers to the realized object. (5) The same scientific term occurring in different scientific theories would then correspond to different scientific concepts.

Some scientific cases, such as carloimetry, thermodynamics, and phlogiston theory, are taken as examples to justify EPT in this article.

關鍵字/Key Word
科學實在論、指稱的因果理論、投射、科學概念、科學哲學
scientific realism, the causal theory of reference, projection, scientific concepts, philosophy of science

全文下載 PDF Download

DOI
--

學門分類/Subject
哲學 Philosophy