出刊年月/Date of Publishing

2021.09

所屬卷期/Vol. & No.   第51卷第3期 Vol. 51, No. 3

類型/Type                 研究論文 Research Article

篇名/Title
從歐盟公共契約法探討具一般經濟利益公共服務之委外
Outsourcing the Public Services of General Economic Interest under EU Public Contract Law

作者/Author
張南薰 Nan-Hsun Chang

頁碼/Pagination
pp. 557-596

摘要
將具有一般經濟利益之公共服務委託私人經營時，可以勞務採購或勞務特許為之。二者在公共服務委外經營上雖扮演重要角色，但與勞務採購不同，勞務特許直至2014年歐盟才通過特許採購指令加以規範。然而，此一指令雖給予勞務特許較明確之定義及較有彈性的選商程序等，但仍存若干問題。勞務特許及勞務採購之區別亦存在疑義，包括如何確認應移轉之風險類型、應移轉風險之程度為何及涉及以公法限制或降低風險時能否符合營運風險之移轉等問題。上述問題在歐盟法院之個案中亦有討論，本文即藉由對相關案例之研究釐清二者之實質內涵與適用關係。

Abstract
In 1999 One of the primary means of outsourcing public services of general economic interest in the EU, service concessions have been excluded from EU directives on public procurement since the first public procurement law was adopted in the 1970s. However, the legal framework on service concessions established under CJEU case-law changed following implementation of the 2014 Directive on Concession, which aimed to bring legal certainty and transparency to procedures associated with choosing concessioners and the performance of concession contracts. This new Directive provides for looser procedures than the 2014 Public Procurement Directive when contracting authorities decide to entrust the delivery of public services to the private sector through concession contracts, but several important issues are left to be clarified, particularly the distinction between public services contracts and service concessions. This article attempts to pro-vide a wholistic picture of the legal frameworks for outsourcing public services in the EU, including via public service contracts and service concessions under the public procurement law and the case-law of CJEU. Following establishment of the frameworks, this article tries to clarify the ambiguous conceptions of public services contracts and service concession through discussion of the various types of risk, and how much risk should be transferred in the determination of contract types. Also, if operational risks are limited, or extremely low due to the supervision of public service under the domestic public law, how is the nature of the contract determined?

關鍵字/Key Word
勞務特許、特許契約、歐盟特許採購指令、歐盟公共採購指令、公私協力關係
service concession, concession contract, EU Directive on Concession, EU Public Procurement Directive, public-private partnership

全文下載 PDF Download

DOI
https://doi.org/10.7015/JEAS.202109_51(3).0004

學門分類/Subject
法學 Law